in

A porn publisher, aggrieved at copyright infringements of its content, is suing Visa and Mastercard for permitting the online theft. Makes an interesting menage-a-trois.

Perfect 10 Inc., which publishes an adult magazine and operates an adult Web site, says hundreds of Web site operators around the world are selling its trademarked images. While Perfect 10 has sued many of these outfits, its biggest beef is with the credit card companies that process the infringers’ transactions. The porn company says that without the support of these financial institutions, infringers wouldn’t be able to steal their stuff.

The credit card companies say requiring them to enforce the property rights of a third party is unheard of and would have ramifications for all service providers.

“It’s an attempt to enforce copyright and trademark liability far beyond any published case ever,” said Mark Jansen, a partner at Townsend and Townsend and Crew who is representing Visa.

“If the court were to impose liability in that context and make companies subject to contributory liability on the basis of aiding and abetting infringement, that would extend across commerce,” he added. “It would convert financial institutions into judges, juries and policemen.”

Perfect 10’s attorney, Howard King, of Los Angeles’ King, Holmes, Paterno & Berliner, agrees that the suit is treading new territory.

“It’s a seminal lawsuit,” he said. “It’s the first time someone has gone to the heart of the financial system and big entities that are drawing huge profits from funding illegal activities. We may fail; we may win.”

King likened the case to the litigation against Napster, whose file-sharing software enabled consumers to swap music over the Internet.

“It is the same general idea,” said King, who represented Metallica and Dr. Dre in their suit against Napster. “Napster wasn’t distributing [music] but providing the means to infringe copyrights.”

Perfect 10 Inc. v. Visa International, 040371, was filed in San Jose, Calif., federal court in January. A hearing on the defendants’ motion to dismiss is set for June 28 before Judge James Ware.

Perfect 10 doesn’t limit its complaint to the theft of its own copyrighted images. The publisher claims the financial institutions are also abetting the theft of supermodel photos from other magazines and “the most treasured film clips (usually nude scenes of top actresses) ever created by motion picture studios.”

The porn publisher claims that since January 2003, it has notified the credit card companies that specific Web sites were infringing its content. Since these financial institutions know about the infringement and financially benefit from it, Perfect 10 says they are liable for contributory and vicarious infringement.

King said the credit card transaction fees are much higher for porn sites because of the shady nature of the business, “which is why we believe they haven’t turned off processing for the sites we’ve showed them are breaking the law.”

British MP George Galloway and his opponent the Daily Telegraph will leave no stone unturned to sort out what could be a spectacular libel case.

One of the authors claiming Dan Brown’s bestseller The Da Vinci Code copied his ideas has admitted he exaggerated his case in an interview with a journalist.