Sir Robert Jones Defamation Case May Settle ‘Racism’ Definition . . But It Also Created Another Knighthood Issue

The defamation trial between Sir Robert Jones and Renae Maihi saw Sir Robert’s lawyer Fletcher Pilditch corrected on his reference to his client as “Sir Jones”, as the Wellington trial commenced today.

Pilditch, a former Crown Prosecutor in Rotorua, will need to be on his mettle for a case involving a satirical column written about Maori in the National Business Review.

Sir Robert, a well known commentator, humourist, libertarian and writer as well as a long-standing businessman and LawFuel contributor, is preparing a robust defence of the allegation of racism. He is seeking a declaration of defamation rather than damages.

[adrotate banner=”90″]

The 2018 column was taken as offensive and resulted in a petition, organised by the defendant Mihi, of almost 70,000 seeking to strip Sir Robert of the knighthood that Pilditch was having difficulty using correctly.

Howeever the clarification of the legal definition of ‘racism’, the issue of free speech and the increasing clamour for strong ‘hate speech’ laws will be a central focus for the case.

Whilst the Human Rights Act prevents speech that may arouse hostility on the grounds of race (among others), the Bill of Rights Act preserves the right to free speech.

>> Latest Law Jobs Here

Recently on LawFuel

• NZ Law Society slams Racist Email Conduct by Law Firm Staff as ‘unsatisfactory’
  Two staff members at a New Zealand law firm have been hit with a formal unsatisfactory conduct finding after a Standards Committee concluded their private email exchanges about a colleague crossed the line… Read more: NZ Law Society slams Racist Email Conduct by Law Firm Staff as ‘unsatisfactory’
• Judge Aitken Northern Club Hearing: NZ First Accounts Branded ‘Rubbish’ as Video Evidence Emerges
  The unprecedented Judicial Conduct Panel hearing into New Zealand District Court Judge Ema Aitken’s alleged disruption of a political function has intensified, with defence counsel dismissing witness testimony as exaggerated and politically motivated.… Read more: Judge Aitken Northern Club Hearing: NZ First Accounts Branded ‘Rubbish’ as Video Evidence Emerges
• NZ Law – Criminal Lawyers Called To Auckland Forum About Struggling System
  >> Looking for a new law job? – Check LawFuel’s Jobs Board In a move that barely ever happens, Chief District Court Judge Heemi Taumaunu has called a forum in Auckland next week… Read more: NZ Law – Criminal Lawyers Called To Auckland Forum About Struggling System
• NZ Legal Profession Hits 17,500 Lawyers as Women Dominate New Intake
  New Zealand’s legal profession is still growing, still skewing young and female, and still overwhelmingly European in makeup, according to the New Zealand Law Society’s 2025 Snapshot of the Profession. As at 30… Read more: NZ Legal Profession Hits 17,500 Lawyers as Women Dominate New Intake
• LawFuel Power List 2025: New Zealand’s Most Influential Lawyers
  NZ Law’s Power Lawyer List 2025 By John Bowie, LawFuel Publisher | The 2025 LawFuel Power List delivers its usual cocktail of institutional heavyweights, courtroom titans, regulatory shock troops, and a few strategists… Read more: LawFuel Power List 2025: New Zealand’s Most Influential Lawyers