By Michael Akiva, Jacoby & Meyers
Most collisions in California are not caused by just one party. One driver may speed up to beat the yellow light, another may look at their phone, and someone else may fail to brake in time. In cases of shared fault, the law determines what will happen to your claim.
California uses a system of comparative fault. This affects how much compensation you’re entitled to after your injuries and will shape almost every conversation with an insurance adjuster. Here is how it works in plain terms.
What the rule says
California follows a “pure” comparative fault system. The state’s high court adopted it in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975), a case built on the idea in Civil Code § 1714 that people are responsible for harm caused by a lack of ordinary care.
The result is simple. If you share some of the blame for a crash, you can still recover money. Your award is reduced by your share of fault.
Some states cut off recovery once a person is 50 or 51 percent at fault. California does not. In theory, a driver who is 90 percent at fault can still collect from the other driver for the remaining 10 percent.
How the math works
Say a jury finds your total damages are $100,000. That covers medical bills, lost pay, and pain and suffering. The jury also decides you were 25 percent at fault because you were going a little over the limit.
Your recovery drops by 25 percent. You would receive $75,000.
The same logic applies when more than one driver is involved. Under Civil Code § 1431.2, each defendant pays non-economic damages, like pain and suffering, only in proportion to that defendant’s share of fault. Economic losses, such as medical bills, follow different rules. That is one reason the fault split matters so much.
Why insurers care about it
Adjusters know the rule well. Every percentage point they can move onto you is money they do not pay.
Here are some arguments they commonly raise:
- You changed lanes without enough room.
- You were driving faster than conditions allowed.
- You looked at your phone before the crash.
- You were not wearing a seat belt, which they may argue made your injuries worse.
- You waited too long to see a doctor, so the injuries must not be serious.
None of these points is automatically fair or true. But they show up in settlement talks again and again, and they can quietly shrink a claim if no one pushes back.
Fault is not decided by the police report alone. A report is one piece of evidence. An insurer, and later a judge or jury, can reach a different view.
Common mistakes after a crash
Small decisions in the first few days can affect how blame is apportioned. Some things to be aware of are:
- Saying “I’m sorry” at the scene. Many people say it out of habit. It can be twisted into an admission later.
- Giving a recorded statement too soon. The other driver’s insurer will often ask for one. Adjusters are trained to ask questions that invite guesses, like “About how fast were you going?” A guess can become a fault argument.
- Skipping medical care. Gaps in treatment give insurers room to argue that your injuries came from something else.
- Posting online. A photo from the weekend or a comment about feeling “fine” can be used against you.
- Missing a deadline. The statute of limitations for most injuries is two years under Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1. If a city, county, or other government agency may be at fault, you generally must file a written claim within six months under Government Code § 911.2. This can be much shorter than people expect.
How evidence changes the fault split
Because the payout depends on the percentages, it’s important to get them right. Usually, strong claims will have detailed information from the beginning, such as:
- Pictures of the vehicles, road and skid marks
- Names and phone numbers of witnesses
- Traffic camera or nearby business video, which is often erased within weeks
- Dashcam footage
- Medical records that tie the injuries to the crash
- Data from the vehicles themselves, where it is available
Jurors get guidance on this exact issue from the Judicial Council’s civil jury instructions. CACI No. 405 covers the plaintiff’s comparative fault and asks the jury to decide whether the injured person was careless and whether that carelessness helped cause the harm.
If an insurer is already blaming you, it may help to speak with a Los Angeles car accident lawyer before you give a recorded statement or accept a first offer. A lawyer can review the evidence, push back on weak fault arguments, and explain what a fair share of responsibility looks like in your case.
What to keep in mind
Comparative fault doesn’t bar you from claiming but will reduce the amount. If you have partial fault for an accident in California, you can still make a claim for what you’re owed.
If you have suffered injuries in an accident, then you should:
- Get medical care and follow the treatment plan.
- Collect photos, witness details, and any video you can.
- Keep your statements short and factual.
- Watch the filing deadlines.
- Get advice before you agree to a settlement.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every crash is different, and the right next step depends on the facts.

Author: Michael Akiva is an attorney with Jacoby & Meyers, a California firm that specialises in assisting people injured in car accidents. Based in the firm’s LA office he began a distinguished legal career after earning his Juris Doctor from UCLA School of Law, where he served as an Editor of the UCLA Law Review.




