NEW YORK, April 25 — Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, who went o…

NEW YORK, April 25 -- Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, who went on a duck hunting trip with Vice President Dick Cheney a few months before the court was slated to hear a case involving Cheney, still refuses to cede any legal ground over the case, believing it would set a terrible precedent to recuse himself under political pressure. But, Newsweek has learned, he has said privately that if he had it to over again, he'd skip the duck hunt, reports Deputy Washington Bureau Chief Debra Rosenberg in the May 3 issue (on newsstands Monday, April 26). Scalia remains as combative as ever publicly, Rosenberg reports, but privately, the justice feels bruised. He was stung by the actions of friend Sen. Patrick Leahy, who sent a sharp letter to Chief Justice William Rehnquist questioning whether Scalia could be "fair and impartial" in the Cheney case. And he grew dismayed that he'd become the butt of late-night jokes. "Sometimes you get so isolated that you lose a sense of how things appear to the rest of the world," Leahy says. Because Scalia doesn't see himself as a raging partisan, he seems baffled that anyone else would. His brand of conservatism is more about the law -- and a strict reading of the Constitution -- than about political ideology. Scalia likes to hire liberal clerks who spar with him in his book-lined chambers. And though his final opinions are full of swagger, the first drafts often reflect more hand-wringing. "It's hard to get it right," he often remarks in chambers, former clerks say. If Scalia's strict reasoning leads him to a seemingly "liberal" result -- as it has in cases involving flag burning, search-and- seizure and pornography -- then so be it. "I don't think Justice Scalia is a politician in a black robe," says E. Joshua Rosenkranz, who clerked for him on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.

NEW YORK, April 25 — Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, who went o…

About The Author

Law Admin

Subscibe to LawFuel

About The Author

Law Admin

Read More