 The Victorian Government has announced its sentencing laws will undergo their first independent review in more than three decades, led by a newly appointed chair of the Sentencing Advisory Council. An RMIT expert warns that translating community views into meaningful reform may prove difficult. Dr Kathryn Daley, Assistant Associate Dean, Social Science Research and Policy Studies: “The purpose of the review, which is said to be independent while having the terms of reference set by the government, is to consult widely to ‘reflect community expectations’, ‘meet the needs of modern Victoria’, and ‘better support victims’ – this is a hugely significant undertaking. “Broad consultation is both inclusive and important – but leads to the expectation that people’s feedback will be considered and acted upon. “This is an impossible task when views on sentencing and punishments are so varied. Almost certainly, experts in the area will disagree strongly with the broader community on what is best, and reconciling those perspectives will be one of the review’s biggest challenges. “If a new Sentencing Act significantly increases minimum jail terms, this might create a neat headline, but it won’t reduce crime, and it won’t reduce the impact on victims. “Governments need to step away from perpetuating the belief that jails are the solution – they do not reduce crime and they are very expensive. A new Act would require a very complicated transition as lawyers and the judiciary interpret and apply it, without having precedents to use. “Reviewing and rewriting the Sentencing Act in a climate as politically charged on crime as Victoria’s is now, makes implementation of potentially unpopular recommendations an act requiring significant political courage.” Dr Kathryn Daley is the Assistant Associate Dean of Social Research and Policy Studies at RMIT University. Her work focuses on policy and practice in areas of crime, youth, homelessness, mental health, and substance use. Media contacts:Interviews: Kathryn Daley, 0412 168 361 or Kathryn.Daley@rmit.edu.au General media enquiries: RMIT External Affairs and Media, 0439 704 077 ornews@rmit.edu.au |
Australia Law – First Sentencing Act review in 30 years faces clash between public expectations and expert evidence
