HSF Kramer’s Australian Profits Stall While the Global Firm Celebrates

Herbertsmith lawfuel

Internal figures obtained by the Australian Financial Review show that HSF Kramer’s Australian business grew profit 1.5 per cent against a 6 per cent budget, showing a problem with the big law business model in the new AI age.

Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer spent July telling anyone who would listen that its first year as a transatlantic firm had beaten every target. Revenue of US$2.4 billion, with a profit of US$850.8 million and profit per equity partner of US$2.05 million.

The firm is spending heavily on AI tools designed to make lawyers faster, inside a business that still gets paid by the hour. Short of changing how it prices work, the only answer is to keep raising rates, and an 8 per cent increase in a year of falling hours suggests the firm is already leaning hard on that lever.

The arithmetic of a stall

Australian lawyers averaged 6.5 billable hours a day against a target of seven. Total billable hours fell 3 per cent and utilisation slipped 2 per cent. But average hourly rates rose 8 per cent.

Put those together and you get the revenue line almost exactly. The firm did not grow by doing more work, it actually grew by charging more for less of it.

But that solution doesn’t last forever and stops when the costs rise faster than prices.

The finance director reportedly told staff that expenses ran over budget, with spending on artificial intelligence part of the reason.

Was it the merger?

It would be tidy to pin this on the Kramer Levin deal, which went live on 1 June 2025 and created a firm of around 2,700 lawyers. The evidence doesn’t support it. The global results were strong, and nothing in the reported figures ties the Australian slowdown to the combination.

The AFR reports that litigation teams stayed busy while parts of the M&A practice went quiet. The firm has also lost transactional firepower. Tony Damian, widely regarded as the country’s leading M&A lawyer, left for Ashurst in 2025 after almost three decades at the firm, and corporate partner Amelia Morgan has since made the same move.

Management is now looking to private capital, data centres and a recovery in deal flow. Whether those turn into billings is another matter.

HSF Kramer Australia is not in trouble (although after the Weil Gotshal demise we all have to be careful about explaining how good law firms are despite their revenue). Profit growth of 1.5 per cent is a disappointment, not a crisis, and plenty of partnerships would happily take it.

We have made the same point about A&O Shearman’s AI spending, and the problem is not going away.

Global scale and all the other PR spin around mergers sound great and help make headlines, but for a firm built on premium advice, premium rates and premium expectations, 1.5 per cent is a distinctly economy-class result.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top