Bob Jones What a hypocritical furore following the government’s announcement lifting the top tax rate from 33% to 39%. That means once over the threshold figure high income earners must now work all Monday and Tuesday before they’re left any money for themselves.
Numerous journalists and diverse economic commentators cried this wasn’t punitive enough. Tax wealth and capital they demanded and specially tax expensive homes.
Now before going any further I shall again tell the story I’ve often recounted that says everything you need to know about tax.
In or about 1991 the then new Bolger Government, in conjunction with Victoria University’s Economics Department, staged a massive tax conference. From memory it lasted about a fortnight.
Every conceivable sector was represented; Federated Farmers, trade unions, educationalists, retailers, exporters, importers, manufacturers, the different professions and so on and on.
Wellington’s two daily newspapers gave good coverage to every address.
It seemed I alone noted the common denominator, specifically that without exception every speaker outlined why society would be better off if their group was taxed less and they honed in on others they felt should be taxed more, for the greater good of society needless to say.
Well, we’ve watched the same scenario play out again since Labour’s 39% announcement.
Low paid journalists and narrow perspective economists, all people unaffected by the increase, have sung in unison, it’s not punitive enough. To quote Rob Muldoon they’re shallow as a birdbath.
Take lightweight broadcaster Jack Tame writing in the Sunday Herald. He arrogantly accused the Prime Minister of “selling out on tax by doing what is popular,” instead of what he, Jack Tame, thinks is right. What he thinks he out-lined and surprise, surprise it involved imposing taxes that wouldn’t affect him. He’s a classic example of the 1991 Conference speakers I’ve described.
Apart from my main proposition that everyone wants low taxes for themselves and more taxes on someone else, there’s another factor at play here, namely my life-long observation of the most powerful human emotion of all, namely envy of the rich.
The fact that the rich in the vast majority of cases deserve their success, their wealth invariably being based on doing something of value to society, of initial personal sacrifice and lots of hard work makes no difference to no-hopers of the smug Jack Tame ilk.
“Punish them” he urges.
Well, boy journalist, try thinking.
Punish the rich and they’ll do one (or more) of three things.
- Ask themselves why bother and go fishing, to society’s loss.
- Work out ways to avoid new punitive taxes specifically targeting them.
- Sell up and take their capital to a less hostile society.
- Nick Williams Joins Britomart ChambersNick Williams has joined Britomart Chambers as a barrister sole. Formerly a litigation partner at Meredith Connell, he specialises in regulatory and commercial litigation, […]
- Cathy Quinn Appointed to Fonterra BoardMinterEllisonRuddWatts consultant, Cathy Quinn ONZM, has been appointed to the board of Fonterra. Prior to retiring from the Partnership. She served as Chair of […]
- Chris Finlayson QC To Receive Honorary Doctorate in Law After Fighting for Maori RightsFormer Attorney General Chris Finlayson QC is to receive an honorary doctorate of Law from Victoria University at the December graduation week. A National […]
- The Power-Lifting, In-House Lawyer Who Dismisses a Harvey Specter Comparison & Rises To CEOIt was not difficult for in-house lawyer Patrick Gamble to shrug off a comparison made by a magazine article that the up-and-coming young legal […]
- Patrick Gamble Named CEO of Perpetual Guardian GroupPatrick Gamble has been named CEO of the Perpetual Guardian Group, a collection of companies delivering market-leading fiduciary and investment services across New Zealand. […]
- Former Liquidator Geoffrey Smith Gets Four Year Prison Term for FraudA former Auckland liquidator has been sentenced to four years’ imprisonment on charges brought by the Serious Fraud Office. Geoffrey Martin Smith (67) stole […]
Get LawFuel Power News Weekly
Subscribe to get our top news weekly