The recent decision in the UK test case on business interruption insurance coverage related to Covid-19 may give an indication on how similar cases in Australia will play out, according to leading law firm Herbert Smith Freehills.
The UK Financial Conduct Authority brought the case on behalf of policyholders and was represented by Herbert Smith Freehills’ insurance team.
The High Court (the first instance Court in the UK) handed down its decision earlier this week and generally ruled in favour of policyholders, finding that various policy extensions can provide coverage for financial losses suffered as a result of the UK’s Covid-19 lockdown, and minimising the ability for insurers to reduce recoveries in reliance on causation arguments.
Herbert Smith Freehills’ insurance partner Mark Darwin said: ‘These issues represent some real pressure points for insurers, both in the UK and Australia. Policyholders should re-examine their policies to see what might be claimable for Covid losses and carefully assess any coverage positions advanced by insurers on these types of losses.’
The Court made key findings on the application of particular coverage extensions to Covid-19 losses and causation issues relating to the impact of Covid-19, including:
- In relation to coverage: The Court considered a variety of extensions which are said to give rise to coverage either as a result of a notifiable disease occurring within a specified area or as a result of prevention of access / action by public authorities. The Court confirmed that various extensions would provide coverage based on the policy worderings considered. Disease extensions had particular success, with the Court confirming that individual outbreaks are indivisible from the general pandemic, meaning that cover was not limited to outbreaks wholly within the geographical area specified in the policy.
- In relation to causation: Insurers argued that the broader impact of the pandemic on the business must be taken into account as a ‘trend’ which would otherwise have affected the policyholder’s business – effectively negating any cover for the immediate local impact of the pandemic. The Court did not accept this argument and did not allow insurers to artificially distinguish between local and national impacts to reduce claimable loss.
A hearing will shortly be fixed with the UK High Court, where any applications for appeal will likely be made.
There are also currently at least two significant cases underway in Australia in respect of Covid-19 business interruption claims. The Australian Financial Complaints Authority and Insurance Council of Australia case in the NSW Supreme Court and the Star Entertainment Group case in the Federal Court are both are in their early stages. Herbert Smith Freehills anticipates that there may be some overlap between the UK decision and these Australian test cases, but that a number of additional issues will be dealt with in the Australian cases.
- Litify Named by LawFuel, the Industry-Leading Legal Publication, as #1 in Practice Management Software for Law Firms, In-House Counsel, Government Entities and NonprofitsPrestigious “top pick” ranking follows a year of explosive growth for Litify across law firms, in-house counsel, government entities and nonprofits NEW YORK, March […] More
- ‘Cutting Edge’ Cryptocurrency Scheme Just Fake, Says US Attorney As Executive Gets 8 Years JailIlan T. Graff, the Attorney for the United States, Acting Under Authority Conferred by 28 U.S.C. § 515, announced that SOHRAB SHARMA, a/k/a “Sam […] More
- “Tremendously Talented” Former Cravath Partner Johnny Skumpija Joins SidleySidley Austin has taken on high profile former Cravath Capital Markets lawyer Johnny Skumpija in an announcement made today. The Sidley press release […] More
- Legal Tech News: Leading AI Legal Platform Adopted By Portugese Law FirmLuminance’s ‘Diligence’ legal tech platform is used by the law firm for M&A due diligence, real estate and data protection compliance Support Independent […] More
- Lowenstein Sandler Grows Tax Practice With New York AdditionsSupport Independent Law News Edmund S. Cohen, Rachel Ingwer, and Scott Malone have joined Lowenstein Sandler’s Tax practice. Cohen and Ingwer will join as partners, and Malone will join […] More
- Former SEC Governance Counsel Joins Sidley in Washington DCWashington, D.C. – Sidley Austin LLP is pleased to announce that Sonia Barros has joined the firm as a partner in its Washington, D.C. office. […] More
- Law Enforcement Agent Arrested For Alleged Bribery SchemeLOS ANGELES – Federal authorities this morning arrested a former special agent with Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) on federal bribery charges that allege he […] More