
The powers used by government to enforce compliance with restrictions on movement have been heavily criticised by former UK supreme court Justice Lord Sumption who has said the public should not be “resigning their liberty” to ovewr-zealous citizens in uniform.
A Guardian article reported the former justice when he heavily criticised Derbyshire police for stopping people exercising saying that such behaviour risks plunging Britain into a “police state”.
Lord Sumption warned that police had no legal power to enforce “ministers’ wishes.”
“This is what a police state is like, it is a state in which a government can issue orders or express preferences with no legal authority and the police will enforce ministers’ wishes,” he said on BBC Radio 4’s World at One.
On Sunday it emerged that Derbyshire police had dyed the usually turquoise water of a lagoon black in the beauty spot to deter tourists from visiting. They took the action as groups were congregating at the disused quarry at Harpur Hill near Buxton.
Recently on LawFuel
- Rebecca KitteridgeLawFuel Power List 2025 No. 2 Kitteridge’s August 2025 appointment as Professor of Practice at Oxford’s Blavatnik School of Government… Read more: Rebecca Kitteridge
- Una JagoseLawFuel Power List 2025 No. 1 Una Jagose may be stepping down in February, but she clings to the top… Read more: Una Jagose
- Buchalter Welcomes New Shareholders to Los Angeles OfficeDecember 10, 2025. Buchalter is pleased to announce that Elizabeth Glasgow and Jennifer Van Duzer have joined the firm’s Los Angeles… Read more: Buchalter Welcomes New Shareholders to Los Angeles Office
- LawFuel US Lawyer of the Year Sigrid McCawleySigrid McCawley: The Lawyer Who Made the Untouchables Touchable Why She’s Our 2025 Lawyer of the Year Sonia Hickey, LawFuel… Read more: LawFuel US Lawyer of the Year Sigrid McCawley
- LawVu Hits $400m Valuation and Goes Full Speed on Legal AITom Borman, LawFuel contributor New Zealand legal tech doesn’t often muscle its way into the global big leagues. LawVu just… Read more: LawVu Hits $400m Valuation and Goes Full Speed on Legal AI
- LawVu Acquires ClauseBase to Expand AI-Powered Workspace For In-House Legal TeamsTauranga, New Zealand — 18 December, 2025 — LawVu, the leading global legal workspace for in-house legal teams, today announced the… Read more: LawVu Acquires ClauseBase to Expand AI-Powered Workspace For In-House Legal Teams
- NZ Law – Russell McVeagh Announces Senior Legal AppointmentsRussell McVeagh is delighted to recognise six outstanding lawyers who have been promoted to Special Counsel and Senior Associate respectively, effective… Read more: NZ Law – Russell McVeagh Announces Senior Legal Appointments