Leading Jurist Talks of Covid-19 “Police State” Moves

The powers used by government to enforce compliance with restrictions on movement have been heavily criticised by former UK supreme court Justice Lord Sumption who has said the public should not be “resigning their liberty” to ovewr-zealous citizens in uniform.

A Guardian article reported the former justice when he heavily criticised Derbyshire police for stopping people exercising saying that such behaviour risks plunging Britain into a “police state”.

Lord Sumption warned that police had no legal power to enforce “ministers’ wishes.”

“This is what a police state is like, it is a state in which a government can issue orders or express preferences with no legal authority and the police will enforce ministers’ wishes,” he said on BBC Radio 4’s World at One.

On Sunday it emerged that Derbyshire police had dyed the usually turquoise water of a lagoon black in the beauty spot to deter tourists from visiting. They took the action as groups were congregating at the disused quarry at Harpur Hill near Buxton.

Recently on LawFuel

• Billing Beyond Reality – When Legal Aid Meets Fantasy Maths
  Samina Ahmed, a Manchester-based solicitor, has been struck off after a Solicitors’ Disciplinary Tribunal found she flagrantly falsified her timesheets… Read more: Billing Beyond Reality – When Legal Aid Meets Fantasy Maths
• Who are the Top Law Tech Innovators in 2026?
  Law technology developments are set to continue their rapid growth in 2026, driven in part by a small group of executives, partners and technologists inside both law firms and specialist vendors who are now setting the agenda for this year and beyond. Many of these leaders hold newly created roles such as chief innovation officer or chief AI officer and are charged with turning generative AI, data and automation into measurable results for clients and the business. ​Authority publications and industry reports on 2025’s top AI and legal tech stories show that generative AI, unified cloud platforms and AI governance will dominate 2026 planning for both firms and in house teams. Log in to see the legal tech leaders . . .
• Skadden Arps Meagher & Flom LLP
  Power Listing Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLPUnited States | GlobalCorporate, Litigation, RegulatoryAuthority Listing — LawFuel Authority Index Why… Read more: Skadden Arps Meagher & Flom LLP
• Understanding the Key Differences Between Tort Law and Personal Injury Law
  Article source: Kass & Moses, Injury Attorneys Tort law and personal injury law often get mentioned together, which can make… Read more: Understanding the Key Differences Between Tort Law and Personal Injury Law
• How an Experienced Car Accident Attorney Like Lawrence Kajy Helps Victims Understand Their Legal Rights
  Article source: Kajy Law Firm, Michigan After a car accident, confusion often sets in just as quickly as the physical… Read more: How an Experienced Car Accident Attorney Like Lawrence Kajy Helps Victims Understand Their Legal Rights
• What Evidence Does the Jury Consider When Deciding Punitive Damages?
  Article source: Brian White Personal Injury Lawyers Texas has a unique legal landscape when it comes to civil lawsuits. The… Read more: What Evidence Does the Jury Consider When Deciding Punitive Damages?
• Understanding the Difference Between a Lawyer and an Attorney
  Article source: Meyers Injury Law Most of us think the terms “lawyer” and “attorney” describe one and the same person—someone… Read more: Understanding the Difference Between a Lawyer and an Attorney