
The Chief Justice has explained that the legal profession has an ‘existential challenge’ to make itself more affordable for lower income clients, saying more funding was also needed for legal aid.
In a rare interview with the Sunday Star-Times, she said that the profession has “failed to innovate” to provide the necessary service to the public.

“If it’s not the legal profession who innovate, they may find themselves losing their exclusive rights of audience in the court,” she says.
“I think that’s an existential challenge to the profession and they need to start coming up with models that meet these needs.”
No Silver Bullet
However the online solution was not the ‘silver bullet’ that some envisaged, she said.
It was an issue that would not be going away any time soon but was one we would need to engage with “forever”.
While there were many looking for an inquisitorial system she believed the ‘sweet spot’ to create a civil court situation that worked properly was somewhere in the middle of the current adversarial system and the inquisitorial one.
The courts’ Rules Committee currently has a programme to solicit ways to improve access to civil justice that seeks public imput and Justice Winkelmann notes the development of the Christchurch Earthquake list and its ability to ‘rocket docket’ cases that required particular urgency.
She noted that Judges were now much more proactive in directing the speed and manner in which cases proceeded, rather than relying on the previous party-driven process that would delay civil trials.
But there has been a dearth of civil claims in the District Court although recent announcements of more Judges may help with both the Attorney General David Parker and Justice Minister Andrew Little focused upon creating greater access to civil justice, which both strongly supported.
See the LawFuel Power List –

Recent Headlines on LawFuel NZ
- The Roy Cohn Industry Continues – His Notoriety Has No Expiry DateMost lawyers are forgotten within a decade of their last billable hour. Roy Cohn, dead for forty years, has become a franchise, it seems. There are biographies, documentaries, a Pulitzer-winning play and an Oscar-nominated… Read more: The Roy Cohn Industry Continues – His Notoriety Has No Expiry Date
- Deborah Chambers KC Adds Her Voice to NZ Law’s Unfinished Gender DebateWhen former NZ Law Society president Jacque Lethbridge told LawFuel that women litigators were still missing out on major briefs and opportunities to lead significant cases, she exposed the polite fiction of the gap… Read more: Deborah Chambers KC Adds Her Voice to NZ Law’s Unfinished Gender Debate
- Crown Law’s Leadership Fight Turns Personal as Deputy Lodges Grievance Against Solicitor-GeneralFirst the union, now one of her own deputies. Six months into the job, Anna Adams KC is defending her Crown Law restructure on two fronts.The Crown Law warfare has become something of an… Read more: Crown Law’s Leadership Fight Turns Personal as Deputy Lodges Grievance Against Solicitor-General
- When Legal Advice Becomes a Licence to Do Nothing and The Justice Ministry’s $500,000 LessonDid Justice Ministry Bosses Need to Use Their Own Power Balls?By John BowieIt took the Ministry of Justice five years, and somewhere between $500,000 and $550,000 of public money, to do what a competent… Read more: When Legal Advice Becomes a Licence to Do Nothing and The Justice Ministry’s $500,000 Lesson
- “Often Still the Only Woman in the Room” – Former Law Society President on NZ’s Litigation GapPower Point: Women in New Zealand lead the judiciary, head the litigation teams at two of New Zealand’s biggest firms and make up most of the profession. But former Law Society President Jacque Lethbridge… Read more: “Often Still the Only Woman in the Room” – Former Law Society President on NZ’s Litigation Gap
Featured – New Diversity Measures For US Law Firms
[adrotate banner=”87″]






