The Roy Cohn Industry Continues – Maybe More Legal History than Legacy

Cohnbook

Most lawyers are forgotten within a decade of their last billable hour. Roy Cohn, dead for forty years, has become a franchise, it seems. There are biographies, documentaries, a Pulitzer-winning play and an Oscar-nominated performance, and the output keeps growing. His role as Donald Trump’s mentor is the chapter that sells books today, but it is only one chapter. Cohn worked for Joe McCarthy and the Mafia, for Cardinal Spellman’s archdiocese and for Studio 54, and he moved between all of them with ease. Each new generation of Cohn-watchers rediscovers him and loses a little more sleep.

There seems to b an entire industry devoted to explaining just how unpleasant he was.

The latest addition is American Scoundrel: Roy Cohn’s Dark Journey from Joe McCarthy to Donald Trump, by Pulitzer Prize-winning biographer Kai Bird with Susan Goldmark.

There’s plenty to work with.

Pick almost any dark corner of postwar American power and Roy Cohn is somewhere in the room – the Red Scare and the Rosenberg executions, the Mob, the Church, high society and the real estate business that produced Donald Trump.

The Trump connection is what keeps Cohn on the bestseller lists, but in many ways it is the least surprising entry on a very long résumé. All these decades later and the books, plays, films and documentaries keep exhuming him, and the people who study him still sound uneasy, as if he might be billing from beyond the grave.

In his early twenties Cohn helped send the Rosenbergs to the electric chair. He then ran Joe McCarthy’s inquisitions (pictured, below) and later in New York he at one time worked for all five of the city’s crime families.

Roycohn joemccarthy lawfuel

He brokered Donald Trump’s 1975 tax deal on the Commodore hotel, and a framed photograph of him reportedly hung in Trump’s office as a negotiating prop. Alan Dershowitz said that where other lawyers kept law books, Cohn’s office held only two: a chequebook and a Rolodex.

The book joins Nicholas von Hoffman’s 1988 biography Citizen Cohn and Sidney Zion’s The Autobiography of Roy Cohn, also published in 1988, which Zion edited from Cohn’s own unfinished manuscript.

On screen, Cohn has been played by James Woods in Citizen Cohn, by Al Pacino in HBO’s Angels in America and by Jeremy Strong in The Apprentice. He is also the subject of two 2019 documentaries. On stage there is Tony Kushner’s Pulitzer-winning play.

The book joins Nicholas von Hoffman’s Citizen Cohn and Sidney Zion’s The Autobiography of Roy Cohn, both published in 1988. On screen, Cohn has been played by James Woods, Al Pacino and Jeremy Strong, and he is the subject of two 2019 documentaries. On stage he is the dark centre of Tony Kushner’s Angels in America.

I have my own small entry in the Cohn file. In 1982, as a young New Zealand lawyer he had no reason to see, I spent an afternoon with him in his gloomy, wood-panelled office on East 68th Street, where he provided an immersing but upbeat interview-come-lounge-about in his generally gloomy office. He was charming, sharp and generous with his time, and he offered introductions in California and tidbits about life in the US.

Cohn book1

He also gave me a signed copy of his How to Stand Up for Your Rights and Win, inscribed “Welcome to the colonies.”

The Roy Cohn of the biographies is a monster. The one I met was a perfect host. Both, I suspect, were entirely genuine.

The book’s central idea is that Trump learned his methods from Cohn, arguing that nobody taught Cohn to be Cohn. Some reviewers of the latest Cohn outing suggests that Cohn is still pulling political strings from beyond the grave, which would have delighted Cohn himself.

What really unsettles the Cohn-watchers is the thought that his methods outlived him – attack, never concede, and claim victory regardless. Who might that remind you of, I wonder?

He was disbarred weeks before his death in 1986. His approach to law as theatre has proved harder to strike off.

Notoriety, unlike a practising certificate, apparently never expires.

Read More –

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top