The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein’s Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated

The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 2

5 Things To Know About Harvey Weinstein’s ‘Bulldog’ Lawyer

The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 3

Image: Chicago Magazine

Harvey Weinstein’s trial is now – at last – about to be heard.  After two years of legal and public turmoil with the disgraced movie mogul forming the epicenter of his greatest prodution: The MeToo Movement, he has a top attorney who is 2 things that might surprise.

First, she’s a woman and second, she’s something of an ‘anti-Metoo’ attorney.


The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 4The onset of the trial of Harve Weinstein will elevate his attorney into the legal stratosphere as the world’s No. 1 #MeToo trial gets under way following delays and controversies along the way.

Weinstein faces five sex crimes and The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 5the court earlier this year consented to former attorneys Ronald Sullivan and Jose Baez, who joined only a couple of weeks’ earlier,  to leave the team.  And to replace them, after preseumably checking the rolodex of star lawyers he might hire,  he has hired a tough, battle-hardened courtroom operator who has specialized in #Metoo actions, representing the male defendants.

Reportedly Weinstein’s former lawyers and client were not getting along, with Baez writing last month: “Mr. Weinstein has engaged in behavior that makes this representation unreasonably difficult to carry out effectively and has insisted upon taking actions with which I have fundamental disagreements.

Enter Donna Rotunno

Rotunno is somewhat unique as an attorney who has worked to defend men charged with sexual harassment.  In the past 15 years, Donna Rotunno has handled over 40 sexual misconduct-related cases, according to Chicago magazine’s 2018 profile

Chicago magazine described her on its cover as “the anti-Gloria Allred.” Rotunno, 44, has embraced the role. Vanity Fair describe her as possessing a Fox News–brand tough with the requisite disdain for “political correctness”.

The Weintein case will proceed in a Manhattan courtroom and is the focus of the first case involving a high profile man who has fallen to the #MeToo movement, focusing global attention on the case.

Expected to last up to six weeks, it will generate mass publicity, involving over 80 women who have accused Wesintein of abuse and sexual harassment.  However it is two cases only that are the focus of the criminal proceeding, one involving former production assistant Mimi Haleyi, who says she was raped in his SoHo home in 2006 and a woman who remains anonymous and claims she was raped at a Manhattan hotel in 2013.

And, like any high profile case, the attorney will also receive a publicity-shot like no other.  For Donna Rotunno, it will be national and global recognition well beyond her Chicago hometown.

 “Any high-profile sex case you hear on the news in Chicago, odds are I’ve gotten a The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 6phone call,” Rotunno said in the profile. She frequently appears with her colleague Damon Cheroni, (both pictured left) who she is again to work with on the Weinstein case.

She has represented a wide range of men who have been accused of sexual crimes, including former Bears cornerback Shaun Gayle, whom Rotunno represented during the investigation of the murder of his girlfriend.   She has also represented Mohammad Abdullah Saleem, an Islamic leader who was accused of molesting a student and a female employee.

1.  She Began as a Prosecutor

A graduate of Chicago-Kent College of Law she began her career prosecuting “deadbeat dads” but contends that sexual assault is a crime with a key flaw.

It is, she says, “the only crime in our statutes where somebody can be charged with zero evidence to back up the allegation, other than someone’s word. … If I went to the 18th District and said, ‘Joh

2. She’s Made a Career Defending Men Accused of Sexual Misconduct

It is no stretch to say that one of the key reasons she defends men accused of sexual misconduct is in large part because she sees her work as upholding the need to ensure justice is being served by providing the best, possible defense.

She has developed a ‘#Metoo Practice’ representing the accused males, noting that “Movements allow emotion to take over.” 

During Rotunno’s brief remarks at the Weinstein hearing today, the lawyer claimed that her client has been “railroaded” by the #MeToo movement, adding at a post-hearing news conference, “The emotion of this case has taken over. There is a truth you have not reported on,”  she told the media.

This is the first time she has discredited the movement, which highlights experiences and stories of sexual assault or violence. “I’m not a woman who has ever subscribed to it. I believe women are responsible for the choices that they make,” she said.

3. She Views Her Gender as an Asset 

Rotunno’s gender provides her with the additional cross examination fire power she seeks, as she can cross-examine with greater “venom” because of it.

“I have the ability to get away with a lot more in a courtroom cross-examining a female than a male lawyer does,” she says. “He may be an excellent lawyer, but if he goes at that woman with the same venom that I do, he looks like a bully. If I do it, nobody even bats an eyelash. And it’s been very effective.”

4.  She’s A Courtroom Bulldog

She is a tough courtroom opponent, regarded by a former Sidley Austin partner as a courtroom bulldog.

Stanley Stallworth, a lawyer and former partner at Sidley Austin, said “She is extremely well prepared, and she is an aggressive defense lawyer who brings her A-game to the courtroom every day.” Those who know both Rotunno and her partner, Cheronis, have also said they are “not surprised” the two lawyers took Weinstein’s case.

5.  She Faces Off Against Another Female Power Lawyer

The Harvey Weinstein Case: Harvey Weinstein's Anti-Metoo Lady Lawyer (And 5 Things You Should Know) . . Updated 7
Image: Fox News Insider

Gloria Allred, who represents one of the alleged Weinstein victims as well as one witness in the criminal trial, held her own news conference outside the courtroom after the change of lawyers.

She released a statement to the media cataloging Rotunno’s statements in media appearances about the advantages conferred upon her by her gender. In a June story in the Wall Street Journal, she said,  Donna Rotunno criticized the #MeToo movement, telling the paper that women needed to be held accountable for their actions.

Ms Allred agreed, but asked when Harvey Weinstein would be held accountable for his.

Two tough lady litigators will see matters unravel – one way or the other – for Harvey Weinstein when his trial gets under way in less than two months’ time.

LawFuel News for Lawyers

ReFuel with the top law news weekly that's fun to read
Powered by ConvertKit
Scroll to Top