The Law Revue Cheaters: Why Above the Law Awards No-One (Yet)

law revue cheaters


Law students cheat? Surely not.  Particularly to win a ‘virtual trophy’ for a Law Review Video competition.

But no, that was the case outlined in a strongly-worded missive on AbovetheLaw by publisher David Lat, who wrote that the stats for alleged visitors and votes for the competition were revealed as being falsified – ie ‘cheating’ – in an audit undertaken by The University of Pennsylvia Law School, which showed what they  called “rampant cheating” by Columbia, UVA and NYU.

Cheating, they wrote.

The UPenn Law letter noted “They (Syracuse) always had the best video (and also, OMG, just a general not giving a s**t about, like, needing to cheat to win a virtual trophy???). I mean, c’mon, Syracuse be throwing delicious shade while those T-3 A**holes be gunnering about trying to get the A+ at any cost. Honey, try emotional fulfillment for once, and a little work/life balance. I promise, you’ll be happier.

In summary:

  • Between April 26 at 6:19pm (web cache permalink) and April 27 at 12:30am, over 7,000 votes were cast for the top 3 videos.
  • During this 12:30am time frame, NYU, Columbia, and UVA had more votes (15,704; 13,950; 9,706, respectively) than YouTube views (9,686; 6,123; 4,956; Penn: 5,431; SU; 7,406; UT: 3,803)
  • At one point, Columbia increased by 1,716 votes in 52 minutes. Compare 12:30am with 1:22am. This is an average of 33 votes a minute, or, a vote every other second.
  • Between 2:08am and 10:54am, an additional 8,000 votes were cast, putting the top 3 within spitting distance of each other, at around 17,000 votes each, almost entirely due to UVA’s last ditch 5,400 vote push (that didn’t even work).

This shows more than 100,000 votes being cast in the contest. But we know, thanks to WordPress and Google Analytics, that the contest voting page did not receive anything close to 100,000 pageviews.

A contest winner? Sorry, Columbia and NYU and UVA — we award you no points, and may character and fitness have mercy on your soul.

The Deserved Winner – Syracuse

Check LawFuel’s Law Jobs Board Here nz law news directory and law jobs and legal services directory

Stress Levels Among lawyers – See here –

The Undeserveds

‘Westside Story’ – Columbia 

Backroom Ballers – University of Virginia

The Law Revue Cheaters: Why Above the Law Awards No-One (Yet)Mean Gunners – University of Pennsylvania 

‘Drunk in Law’ – NYU

“I’m Not Hiring You” – Texas University


Join The New LawFuel Legal Jobs Group – The Water Cooler Jobs Tip Here

The Law Revue Cheaters: Why Above the Law Awards No-One (Yet)


3 thoughts on “The Law Revue Cheaters: Why Above the Law Awards No-One (Yet)”

  1. Unclear whether you were unintentionally throwing shade but the letter regarding cheating that was sent to ATL came from UPenn Law, the producers of the Mean Gunners video, NOT from Penn State.

  2. This article incorrectly credits Penn State instead of the University of Pennsylvania Law School (Penn Law). Penn State did not compete, wore sweatpants on Monday, and thus can’t sit with us. That’s just, like, the rules of feminism.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top