Sam Stubbs* – The FMA this week released its report into active and passive management styles, which found that there was no clear correlation between passive management and lower fees – and that fees had not dropped to the extent that would be expected.
“While investment management fees have declined globally, and economies of scale for the larger KiwiSaver providers have grown considerably, these lower input costs have not resulted in systemically lower fees to KiwiSaver investors,” the FMA said.
“We would have expected to have seen fee levels decline further than they have given the fall in input costs. Overall, our results suggest that value for money in some KiwiSaver products is not as high as it could be. With greater competition and scrutiny, we would expect over time to see fees more closely aligned to the investment strategy, and lower KiwiSaver fees overall.”
Stubbs said providers would continue to opt for the “easy way out” on fees unless the FMA was able to force them.
Taking a provider to court over their fees would send a clear message that “willful ignorance was not a viable business strategy going forward”, he said.
He said the report discredited the argument that fees were high because providers were adding value.
“It’s not true that active management costs that much. Ninety per cent of the cost is stuff you have to do regardless of your management style.”
He said regulating fees would be difficult but taking a case to court would mean that a benchmark for what was “unreasonable” would be set – rather than relying on the regulator to determine what was reasonable.
“There are some insane fees out there.”
He said the FMA had the ability and obligation to make sure that fees were reasonable.
It would become more pressing an issue if returns suffered in the years ahead, he said.
FMA spokesman Andrew Park said the report raised important questions but there was not yet sufficient information to conclude there were conduct issues.
“We are following up with those providers where the claims of active management style are not matched by the activity delivered, and where the fees are not aligned with the level of active management revealed in the report. Where we do find misleading behaviour we will take action, which may include – but is not limited to – requiring corrections in disclosure materials.”
First published on GoodReturns.co.nz
Author Bio
Sam Stubbs is managing director of online KiwiSaver company Simplicity. He was most recently the CEO Of Tower Investments. Before that he was Managing Director of Hanover Group, and spend 10 years working for Goldman Sachs in London and Hong Kong.
- In-House Power LawyersSky City legal counsel Jo Wong on the LawFuel In-House Power list
- Unveiling the Auckland Mayoral Splurge: Big Bucks on Law Firms and ConsultantsAuckland Mayor Wayne Brown recently expressed shock at the substantial expenditures made by his council on legal firms and consultants, but …
Unveiling the Auckland Mayoral Splurge: Big Bucks on Law Firms and Consultants Read More »
- NZ AML Tech Developer Partners With Actionstep For Global AML ComplianceAnti money laundering startup First AML from New Zealand has partnered with Actionstep to provide global AML tech solutions
- Growth of New Zealand Bar: Which Are the Largest Chambers?Which are the largest barristers’ chambers in New Zealand?
- Grim Day For Grimshaws After Court JudgmentGrimshaw & Co achieved a $20.1 million win for their clients over a leaky building claim in respect of a Takapuna …
- New Zealand Law & White Collar Crime –A debate should be held regarding the way in which white collar crime is dealt with in New Zealand law compared to other types of crime, where there is greater leniency and immunity
- Frazer Barton Re-Elected To Head NZLS – With Challenges AheadThe Law Society of New Zealand has confirmed that Anderson Lloyd partner Frazer Barton will continue to serve as President for …
Frazer Barton Re-Elected To Head NZLS – With Challenges Ahead Read More »